Track · Product Strategy3 min read
Colgate's Frozen Meals and the Segmentation Errors That Kill Products
Colgate's 1980s frozen meals failed within a year — a segmentation error no advertising could fix. Oluwole Dada's STP breakdown explains the four tests segments must pass first.

Context
Colgate launched frozen ready meals in the US in the 1980s; the brand extension failed within a year due to a segmentation error.
A viable segment must pass four criteria: identifiable, accessible, substantial, and responsive.
Mid-2000s Nigerian telcos targeted the unbanked rural population with mobile financial services but failed on accessibility — limited network coverage, missing handsets, no agent proximity.
M-Pesa in Kenya succeeded partly because Safaricom built its agent network before aggressively scaling consumer acquisition.
Colgate launched a range of frozen ready meals in the United States in the 1980s, and the product failed within a year — not because of weak advertising or thin distribution, but because the segment it targeted was never responsive to a Colgate food product in the first place. The failure was baked in at the whiteboard, months before anything reached a shelf.
That is the argument of Oluwole Dada, a general management and commercial executive and author of THE LEADER'S LEVERAGE, in the latest instalment of his series on why products fail. His claim: most fatal product decisions happen in a room where someone draws a box on a whiteboard, writes "our target consumer" inside it, and either draws it around the wrong people or draws it correctly and then ignores it at execution.
What is STP, and why does it come first?
Segmentation, Targeting, and Positioning (STP) is the foundational framework of product commercialisation, Dada writes. It precedes pricing, distribution strategy, and advertising because every other commercial decision depends on the answers it produces:
- Segmentation — who is this product for?
- Targeting — within that group, which consumers get the concentrated resources?
- Positioning — how should those consumers think and feel about the product relative to everything else available?
Get all three right and you have a commercial platform. Get any one wrong, and no amount of marketing investment fixes it. Dada covers positioning in detail in the next instalment; this piece is about the first two.
When does a segment pass the test?
Segmentation divides a broad market into groups sharing characteristics relevant to their relationship with a product. The standard variables are:
- Demographics — age, income, gender, household size
- Geographics — region, urban or rural, climate
- Psychographics — lifestyle, values, attitudes, personality
- Behavioural variables — purchase frequency, brand loyalty, usage occasion, benefit sought
The variables are textbook material. The discipline is not. Dada sets four criteria a segment must meet before it is worth targeting:
- Identifiable — you can describe the people precisely enough to find them.
- Accessible — you can reach them through the channels and media you actually have.
- Substantial — the group is large and economically active enough to generate viable revenue.
- Responsive — the people in it actually need or want what the product offers.
Fail any one test, and the product has been aimed at a ghost.
How did the failures play out?
Colgate's segmentation logic looks, in retrospect, easy to critique. The company identified health-conscious consumers as a growth segment and tried to extend its oral care brand equity into food. The segment was real, identifiable, and substantial. The error sat in the behaviour variable: the behaviour pattern of health-conscious consumers around oral hygiene did not overlap with their meal choices in any commercially useful way. The segment existed but was not responsive to a Colgate food product. No distribution or advertising spend could repair the error at the foundation.
The Nigerian market supplies the mirror-image case. In the mid-2000s, several telcos launched mobile financial services targeting the unbanked rural population. The segmentation was directionally correct — a large population, low banking penetration, an identifiable need. The failure came on accessibility. Many targeted consumers lived where network coverage was limited, did not own the required entry-level handsets, and lacked proximity to an agent network that would make the service practically usable. Products that scaled commercial expectations before the infrastructure matured ended with failed launches.
M-Pesa in Kenya succeeded partly because Safaricom built its agent network before aggressively scaling consumer acquisition. Accessibility was solved before targeting expanded.
What should product managers take from this?
Targeting is the concentration of marketing resources on a specific group, and its purpose is waste avoidance. Once a viable segment clears all four tests, the correct move is disciplined focus rather than broad spend. The hard part is that a segment can pass three of the four tests and still be a ghost — real, findable, and large, yet unreachable or unmoved.
As launch cycles compress and growth teams face pressure to scale acquisition early, the sequencing lesson — solve accessibility before you widen targeting — is becoming the difference between an M-Pesa and a write-off.
via businessday.ng (Source)
More from Nathan Brooks
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering companies, deals and strategy in product management at Roadmap File.
56 articles