Track · Product Strategy3 min read
Italy Fines Meta €805 Million Over Android Gallery Access
Italy fined Meta €805 million after finding Facebook accessed Android photo galleries by default without specific consent, and ordered the feature disabled in 60 days.

Context
Italy fined Meta €805 million ($887 million), about 0.47% of global turnover.
The Facebook feature 'Get suggestions from gallery' was enabled by default for roughly 20 million Italian Android users.
Meta has 60 days to disable the feature and obtain separate user consent.
The fine targets Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, which had challenged Italy's jurisdiction.
Italy's data protection authority has hit Meta with an €805 million ($887 million) fine for accessing photos and videos in Android users' galleries without proper consent — a penalty equal to roughly 0.47 per cent of the group's global turnover.
The Italian Data Protection Authority announced the decision on Saturday. At the center of the case is a Facebook feature called "Get suggestions from gallery when browsing Facebook," which the regulator found violated a European privacy directive that Italy has incorporated into its national law.
The stakes are large by any measure: Italy has about 20 million Android users, and the authority says the feature reached into a part of their lives the law treats as off-limits without explicit permission.
What did the regulator actually find?
The directive, as the authority interprets it, protects smartphones as part of an individual's private sphere. Before an app can touch that sphere, it needs what the regulator calls "free and informed consent" — consent that is specific, disclosed clearly, and not bundled into something else.
Investigators found two problems with how Facebook handled it.
- The feature was enabled by default. Users weren't opting in; they were opted in unless they noticed and acted.
- Consent was bundled. Facebook sought access to users' galleries through a single permission that covered multiple app functions with different purposes — meaning a user agreeing to one thing was, in practice, agreeing to several.
That bundling is the heart of the case. Under European privacy rules, consent for one purpose can't be smuggled in alongside consent for another, and it can't be pre-ticked by default.
The takeaway: a default-on setting that folds gallery access into a broader permission is exactly what European regulators consider non-consent, no matter how many users clicked through it.
What happens next for Meta?
The authority has given Meta 60 days to disable the feature and obtain separate consent from users before it runs again. That's a hard deadline, and it forces a product change, not just a payment — the feature cannot operate on the old permission model even if Meta pays the fine.
Meta did not immediately comment on the decision.
The fine was imposed on Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, the subsidiary through which the company operates across much of Europe. That entity had challenged Italy's jurisdiction over the matter, according to the authority — a procedural fight it has now lost, at least at this stage.
The regulator also said Meta's "lack of cooperation" during the investigation factored into the size of the penalty. In other words, how a company behaves during a probe is itself a variable regulators will price in.
The takeaway: jurisdictional challenges and a difficult investigative posture didn't shield Meta — and may have made the number bigger.
Why this matters beyond Italy
For product teams, the ruling lands as a concrete warning about consent architecture. A single permission covering multiple purposes with different intents is not just a compliance risk in Italy; it runs against the logic of the European directive that underpins privacy enforcement across the EU. Any feature that reads user media — photos, videos, galleries — on a default-on basis, or piggybacks on a broader permission, now has a €805 million precedent attached to it.
The case also fits a pattern of mounting pressure on Meta in Europe. Thailand's Consumer Council has separately sued Meta over scam advertisements, and privacy regulators across the continent have repeatedly targeted how the company obtains consent for data processing.
Italy's 20 million Android users represent a fraction of Meta's global base, but the principle the authority applied — smartphones as private sphere, consent as specific and unbundled — travels well beyond Italian borders.
The takeaway: consent design is now a board-level cost item, and the cheapest time to unbundle permissions is before a regulator does it for you.
Expect European regulators to keep treating default-on data access and bundled permissions as the same defect, with fines scaled to global turnover — which means consent flows deserve the same rigor as any revenue-critical feature.
via tribuneonlineng.com (Source)
More from Daniel Okafor
Show full bio
Staff writer covering technology and product news in product management at Roadmap File.
60 articles