Track · AI in Product4 min read
McClatchy Rebuilds Around AI as Digital Traffic Falls 39%
McClatchy lost 17% of digital subscribers and 39% of unique visitors in a year. Its answer: Project Catalyst, an AI-native operating model spanning editorial, ads, finance and four new Trend Hunter-powered brands.
Context
McClatchy's paid digital subscribers fell 17% and unique visitors fell 39% over the past year.
September layoffs cut more than 90 journalists, including at the Miami Herald and The Kansas City Star.
Project Catalyst embeds AI agents across editorial, advertising, finance, legal and admin operations.
Originality.ai estimates up to 20% of recent McClatchy articles may be AI-generated.
Four new digital brands run on Trend Hunter, acquired in 2024; strategy was outlined at a Nov. 6 town hall.
McClatchy's paid digital subscribers fell 17% and unique visitors dropped 39% over the past year, figures executives disclosed at a Nov. 6 employee town hall as they pitched a companywide restructuring around artificial intelligence.
The 169-year-old publisher, which operates 29 daily newspapers across 14 states, is shifting resources away from traditional local journalism toward AI-assisted publishing, automated business operations and new interest-based digital brands covering sports, outdoor recreation, crime and lifestyle content. The November 18 Nieman Lab report, based on audio of the meeting, revealed the full scope of the plan.
CEO Tony Hunter told employees the old operating model is finished. "We cannot continue to do the same things because the marketplace has changed," Hunter said, according to Nieman Lab. The company has faced sustained financial pressure since hedge fund Chatham Asset Management acquired it in 2020, and executives acknowledged that substantial debt obligations continue to limit financial flexibility.
The transformation follows September layoffs affecting more than 90 journalists, including staff at the Miami Herald and The Kansas City Star.
What is Project Catalyst?
At the center of the plan sits Project Catalyst, an initiative to integrate AI agents throughout editorial, advertising, finance, legal and administrative operations. Chief Operating Officer Jeff Dorsey described it as an "AI-native operating model" that automates repetitive work and embeds intelligent software directly into employee workflows.
Deployments already span the business:
- Editorial production: repackaging articles, generating content, identifying trending topics
- Audience development: personalizing content distribution by reader interest
- Subscriber retention: flagging customers at risk of canceling
- Advertising sales: identifying potential advertisers
- Financial operations: forecasting revenue, streamlining administration
- Content verification: assisting with headline reviews and quality checks
Executives said the goal is reducing operating costs while employees manage larger workloads. Chief Product and Engineering Officer Rajiv Pant stressed that people remain responsible for directing the technology and evaluating its output.
The shift matters because it moves AI from editorial support tool to core operating infrastructure — a distinction with real consequences for how product and operations teams are structured.
Where do the new audiences come from?
McClatchy is building four new digital brands targeting national audiences around shared interests rather than geographic markets. The sites run on Trend Hunter, an AI-driven consumer trends company McClatchy acquired in 2024. The publishing model combines automated content creation, audience analytics, consumer product coverage and sponsored content.
The Content Innovation Lab, led by former ESPN digital executive Patrick Stiegman, develops these brands. The bet: interest-based publishing can attract sponsorships and commerce revenue beyond conventional display advertising, and reach readers outside any single newspaper market.
What happens to editorial credibility?
The AI expansion has already drawn resistance from the newsroom. Earlier this year, reporters at several McClatchy papers refused to attach bylines to articles produced by an automated content-scaling system that repackages existing reporting.
Estimates from AI-detection company Originality.ai suggest as much as 20% of recent McClatchy articles may have been AI-generated. That figure is inherently uncertain — detection tools cannot reliably distinguish all machine-generated text from human writing.
Journalists have also criticized lifestyle and consumer-product articles with little relevance to local communities. Kristine Sherred, chair of the Washington State NewsGuild and a reporter at The News Tribune in Tacoma, questioned whether the strategy still aligns with the company's journalism mission. The union has pushed for ethical limits on AI use, arguing automated production should not displace original reporting or local government accountability.
Hunter said the company intends to preserve standards for accuracy and relevance while building a more efficient operating model.
Can the economics work?
CFO Joe Settineri acknowledged at the town hall that debt obligations consume a substantial portion of available profitability, limiting reinvestment. McClatchy is effectively trying to finance its next generation of digital products while stabilizing existing newspapers.
The structural pressure extends beyond one publisher: declining referral traffic, subscription fatigue, shifting advertising economics, and AI-powered search engines that answer questions without sending readers to the source. For businesses dependent on pageviews and subscriptions, that threatens the revenue model directly.
The tradeoff is unresolved. AI can lower publishing costs, but cutting newsroom staffing risks weakening the original reporting that separates legacy publishers from automated content farms. As automated content spreads, exclusive reporting and trusted local relationships may become more valuable, not less.
McClatchy's restructuring is among the most aggressive attempts by a legacy newspaper company to rebuild around AI, and it doubles as a live experiment for the industry: whether AI-driven efficiency plus interest-based digital revenue can sustain a news business without eroding the journalism that built it.
via citybiz.co (Source)
More from Marcus Bennett
Show full bio
Market editor covering regulation, policy and their impact on product management at Roadmap File.
56 articles